Attachment 542 Details for Bug 4865 – Test protocol of keyboards in different platform / browser combinations.

Test protocol of keyboards in different platform / browser combinations.

bug4865_keyboard_test.md (text/x-markdown), 17.21 KB, created by Henrik Andersson on 2014-05-12 14:15:36 CEST

(hide)

Description:

Filename:

MIME Type:

Creator: Henrik Andersson

Created: 2014-05-12 14:15:36 CEST

Size: 17.21 KB

patch

obsolete

>
>Test cases
>==========
>
>Basics
>------
>
>- Verify basic text writnig and symbols such as;
>
>  - Â¡@Â£$â¬Â¥{[]}\Â± (altgr - full top row Â§ - ')
>  - !"#Â¤%&/()=? (shift - full top row)
>
>- Disabling use of input methods like pinyen
>- Focus release, eg ctrl-t for new tab verify that ctrl is release
>  in the session.
>- Keyrepeat
>- Key press order, test using shift + a, and match behaviour with local.
>- Multikey press, verify that keyrepeat is disabled if pressing ab
>  and releasing b before keyrepeat.
>
>
>Modifiers
>---------
>
>Verify that modifiers sends correct key using xev.
>  
>- Left / right shift, ctrl, super
>- altgr
>- ctrl-c / ctrl-v
>- @ (altgr - 2)
>- CAPITALS (shift - text...)
>- emacs (ctrl-shift-d)
>
>
>Dead keys
>---------
>
> - Ãº Ã¹
> - Ã» Ç (shift - altgr - ^)
> - Å© Ã¼
> - Ã§ (altgr-,)
> - Å¯ (shift - altgr - Ã¥)
> - á»¥ (altgr - - - u)
>
>
>Keypad
>------
>
>Test all keys with and without num-lock state and verify that correct
>symbols are sent.
>
>
>Function keys
>-------------
>
>- menu key
>- F1-F12
>- media keys
>- pause
>- print screen
>
>
>State keys
>----------
>
>None of the state keys are synced client/server but should provide
>correct behaviour.
>
>- Test that caps-lock works as expected, sends (Shift_L + <sym>)
>- Test that num-lock works as expected
>
>
>Testing protocol
>================
>
>    | OS      | Browser        | Basics                       | Mods                               | DeadKey      | Keypad              | Function keys                | State keys |
>    |---------+----------------+------------------------------+------------------------------------+--------------+---------------------+------------------------------+------------|
>    | Linux   | Chrome         | X                            | [1], [2]                           | [3]          | [4]                 | [5], [6], [7], [9]           | X          |
>    |         | FireFox        | X                            | [10], [11]                         | [12]         | [13]                | [14], [15]                   | X          |
>    |---------+----------------+------------------------------+------------------------------------+--------------+---------------------+------------------------------+------------|
>    | Windows | IE 11          | X                            | [16], [17], [18]                   | [19]         | [20]                | [21], [22], [23]             | X          |
>    |         | FireFox        | X                            | [24], [25], [26]                   | [27]         | [28]                | [29], [30], [31]             | X          |
>    |         | Chrome         | X                            | [32], [33], [34], [35]             | [36]         | [37]                | [38], [39], [40]             | X          |
>    |         | Safari         |                              |                                    |              |                     |                              |            |
>    |---------+----------------+------------------------------+------------------------------------+--------------+---------------------+------------------------------+------------|
>    | OS X    | FireFox        | X                            | [41],[42]                          | [43]         | [44], [45]          | [46], [47], [48], [49], [50] | [51]       |
>    |         | Chrome         | X                            | [52], [53], [54]                   | [55]         | [56], [57]          | [58], [59], [60], [61], [62] | [63]       |
>    |         | Safari         | X                            | [64], [65], [66], [67], [68], [69] | [70]         | [71], [72]          | [73], [74], [75], [76], [77] | [78]       |
>    |---------+----------------+------------------------------+------------------------------------+--------------+---------------------+------------------------------+------------|
>    | iOS     | Safari (Virt)  | [79], [80], [81]             | X                                  | N/A          | N/A                 | [82]                         | X          |
>    |         | Safari (HW)    | [83], [84], [85]             | [86], [87]                         | [88], [89]   | N/A                 | [90], [91]                   | [92]       |
>    |         | Chrome (Virt)  | -                            | Chrome timeouts during load of     |              |                     |                              |            |
>    |         | Chrome (HW)    |                              | HTML5 client. tlstunnel problem ?  |              |                     |                              |            |
>    |---------+----------------+------------------------------+------------------------------------+--------------+---------------------+------------------------------+------------|
>    | Android | Chrome (Virt)  | [93], [94], [95], [96], [97] | X                                  | N/A          | N/A                 | [98]                         | X          |
>    |         | FireFox (Virt) | [99], [100], [101], [102]    | X                                  | N/A          | N/A                 | [103]                        | X          |
>    |         | Chrome (HW)    | [104]                        | [105], [106], [107], [108], [109]  | [110]        | [111], [112], [113] | [114], [115], [116], [117]   | X          |
>    |         | FireFox (HW)   | [118]                        | [119], [120], [121]                | [122], [123] | [124], [125]        | [126], [127], [128]          | X          |
> 
>
>Linux - Google Chrome v34.0.1847.132
>------------------------------------
>
>[1] Right shift and ctrl is sent as left counterparts.
>
>[2] Left super is sent as right counterpart (Super_R) and right super
>is sent with strange keycodes;
>
>    KeyRelease event, serial 50, synthetic NO, window 0x1000001,
>	 root 0xed, subw 0x0, time 7812445, (80,92), root:(166,137),
>     state 0x41, keycode 50 (keysym 0xffe1, Shift_L), same_screen YES,
>     XLookupString gives 0 bytes: 
>     XFilterEvent returns: False
>
>    KeyRelease event, serial 50, synthetic NO, window 0x1000001,
>     root 0xed, subw 0x0, time 7813613, (80,92), root:(166,137),
>     state 0x40, keycode 207 (keysym 0x0, NoSymbol), same_screen YES,
>     XLookupString gives 0 bytes: 
>     XFilterEvent returns: False
>
>[3] Dead key Ë does not work.
>
>[4] No keys on keypad are sent as KP_ keys.
>
>[5] Menu key brings up local application context menu, not sent into
>session even if unbound from gnome-shell.
>
>[6] Print Screen not sent into session.
>
>[7] Pause is not sent into session.
>
>[9] Media keys is handled locally, not sent into session. If I unbound
>a mediakey X86Tools for example, it is sent into session but as wrong
>key.
>
>	local: keycode 179 (keysym 0x1008ff81, XF86Tools)
>    session: keycode 222 (keysym 0xffca, F13)
>
>
>Linux - FireFox v29.0
>---------------------
>
>[10] Right shift and ctrl is sent as left counterparts.
>
>[11] Left and right super is sent as right super.
>
>[12] No dead keys works at all.
>
>[13] No keys on keypad are sent as KP_ keys.
>
>[14] Print screen is handled locally, not sent into session. If i
>unbound keyboard shortcut in gnome-shell, wrong keys are sent to
>server, see following session side events:
>
>    KeyPress event, serial 37, synthetic NO, window 0x3a00001,
>     root 0xec, subw 0x0, time 364819555, (112,78), root:(177,933),
>	 state 0x0, keycode 50 (keysym 0xffe1, Shift_L), same_screen YES,
>	 XLookupString gives 0 bytes: 
>	 XmbLookupString gives 0 bytes: 
>	 XFilterEvent returns: False
>	
>    KeyPress event, serial 37, synthetic NO, window 0x3a00001,
>     root 0xec, subw 0x0, time 364819555, (112,78), root:(177,933),
>	 state 0x1, keycode 51 (keysym 0x2a, asterisk), same_screen YES,
>	 XLookupString gives 1 bytes: (2a) "*"
>	 XmbLookupString gives 1 bytes: (2a) "*"
>	 XFilterEvent returns: False
>
>    KeyRelease event, serial 37, synthetic NO, window 0x3a00001,
>     root 0xec, subw 0x0, time 364819555, (112,78), root:(177,933),
>     state 0x1, keycode 50 (keysym 0xffe1, Shift_L), same_screen YES,
>     XLookupString gives 0 bytes: 
>     XFilterEvent returns: False
>
>    KeyRelease event, serial 37, synthetic NO, window 0x3a00001,
>     root 0xec, subw 0x0, time 364819595, (112,78), root:(177,933),
>     state 0x0, keycode 51 (keysym 0x27, apostrophe), same_screen YES,
>     XLookupString gives 1 bytes: (27) "'"
>     XFilterEvent returns: False
>
>[15] No media keys are sent into session.
>
>
>Windows - IE11 v11.0.9600.16521
>-------------------------------
>
>[16] Right ctrl, shift is sent as left counterpart
>
>[17] altgr is sent as (Control_L + Alt_L)
>
>[18] right super is sent as (Shift_L + Hyper_L)
>
>[19] Ç, Å©, Ã§, Å¯ doesn't work at all. I assume this is a side affect of
>windows sending control+alt instead of altgr.
>
>[20] No keys on keypad are sent as KP_
>
>[21] No media keys are sent into session.
>
>[22] pause is not sent into session.
>
>[23] print screen is not sent into session.
>
>
>Windows - FireFox v29.0
>-----------------------
>
>[24] Right ctrl, shift is sent as left counterpart
>
>[25] Left and rigth super is both sent as Super_R
>
>[26] altgr is sent as (Control_L + Alt_L)
>
>[27] No altgr based deadkeys are working, same reason as with IE11
>
>[28] No keys on keypad are sent as KP_
>
>[29] No media keys works except that volume up / down was sent into
>session but with strange symbols.
>
>       Volume Up: keycode 178 (keysym 0xb7, periodcentered)
>    Volumer Down: keycode 254 (keysym 0xb6, paragraph)
>
>[30] print screen not sent into session.
>
>[31] pause not set into session.
>
>
>Windows - Google Chrome v34.0.1847.131 m
>----------------------------------------
>
>[32] Right ctrl, shift is sent as left counterpart
>
>[33] Left super is sent as Super_R
>
>[34] Right super is sent as (Shift_L + Hyper_L)
>
>[35] altgr is sent as (Control_L + Alt_L)
>
>[36] No altgr based deadkeys are working, same reason as with IE11
>
>[37] No keys on keypad are sent as KP_ keys.
>
>[38] No media keys is sent into session.
>
>[39] pause is not sent into session.
>
>[40] print screen is not sent into session.
>
>
>Mac OS X - FireFox v29.0
>------------------------
>
>[41] Right ctrl, shift, alt (Mac keyboard) is sent as left counterpart.
>
>[42] Command key is sent as (Shift_L + Meta_L), ISO_Group_Lock
>
>[43] Dead keys are broken in several ways, I couldn't find any that
>worked at all.  If you hit _grave_ you will end up with a capital
>_agrave_;
>
>    KeyPress event, serial 82, synthetic NO, window 0x1000001,
>     root 0xed, subw 0x0, time 27122545, (138,70), root:(224,115),
>     state 0x0, keycode 50 (keysym 0xffe1, Shift_L), same_screen YES,
>     XLookupString gives 0 bytes: 
>     XmbLookupString gives 0 bytes: 
>     XFilterEvent returns: False
>
>    KeyPress event, serial 82, synthetic NO, window 0x1000001,
>     root 0xed, subw 0x0, time 27122545, (138,70), root:(224,115),
>     state 0x1, keycode 154 (keysym 0xc0, Agrave), same_screen YES,
>     XLookupString gives 2 bytes: (c3 80) "Ã"
>     XmbLookupString gives 2 bytes: (c3 80) "Ã"
>     XFilterEvent returns: False
>
>    KeyRelease event, serial 82, synthetic NO, window 0x1000001,
>     root 0xed, subw 0x0, time 27122545, (138,70), root:(224,115),
>     state 0x1, keycode 50 (keysym 0xffe1, Shift_L), same_screen YES,
>     XLookupString gives 0 bytes: 
>     XFilterEvent returns: False
>
>    KeyRelease event, serial 82, synthetic NO, window 0x1000001,
>     root 0xed, subw 0x0, time 27122646, (138,70), root:(224,115),
>     state 0x0, keycode 154 (keysym 0xe0, agrave), same_screen YES,
>     XLookupString gives 2 bytes: (c3 a0) "Ã "
>     XFilterEvent returns: False
>
>[44] Num lock has no effect, neither on mac and pc keyboard. Numbers
>are always sent.
>
>[45] No keys on keypad is sent as KP_ keys.
>
>[46] F11, F12, F14 ,F15 (Mac keyboard) is not sent into session.
>
>[47] F13 (Mac) is sent as _comma_ into session
>
>[48] No media keys are sent into session
>
>[49] Print screen (PC) is sent as _comma_ into session, same physical
>placement as F13 on mac keyboard.
>
>[50] Pause not sent into session.
>
>[51] Num lock doesn't work at all, locally on mac.
>
>
>Mac OS X - Google Chrome v34.0.1847.131
>---------------------------------------
>
>[52] Left / right command sent as (Shift_L + Meta_L)
>
>[53] Right shift,ctrl,alt (mac) sent as left counterpart
>
>[54] atlgr (PC) sent as Alt_L
>
>[55] No dead keys works at all
>
>[56] Num lock has no effect, neither on mac and pc keyboard. Numbers
>are always sent.
>
>[57] No  keys on keypad is sent as KP_ keys.
>
>[58] F11, F12 is captured locally and not sent into session.
>
>[59] F14, F16 (Mac) is not sent into session.
>
>[60] Menu key (PC) is sent as Shift_L
>
>[61] No media keys are sent into session
>
>[62] Print screen (PC) is sent as F13, same physical key as F13 key on
>Mac keyboard.
>
>[63] Num lock doesn't work at all, locally on mac.
>
>
>Mac OS X - Safari v7.0.3
>------------------------
>
>[64] Right shift,ctrl,alt (mac) sent as left counterpart
>
>[65] Left command key is sent into session as (Shift_L + Meta_L) + Super_R
>
>[66] Right command key is sent into session as (Shift_L + Meta_L) + Menu
>
>[67] Menu key (PC) is sent as Shift_L
>
>[68] alt+space is sent as (Alt_L + nobreakspace)
>
>[69] Alt state can be hung within a session pressing the following key
>sequence on a PC keyboard. No KeyRelease will be sent for Meta_L and
>the concequenses are that any key sent is modified by alt until alt
>key is pressed to release the state. The problem is probably in the
>javascript code. (All browsers)
>
>  menu (down) -> windows (down) -> menu (up) -> windows (up)
>
>
>[70] No dead keys works at all
>
>[71] No keys on keypad is sent as KP_ keys
>
>[72] Num lock has no effect, neither on mac and pc keyboard. Numbers
>are always sent.
>
>[73] F11,F12 is captured locally and not sent into session.
>
>[74] F14, F15 is not sent into session.
>
>[75] menu key (PC) sent as Shift_L
>
>[76] No media keys
>
>[77] Print Screen sent as F13 (PC)
>
>[78] Num lock doesn't work at all, locally on mac.
>
>
>iPad iOS v7.1.1 - Safari - Virtual Keyboard
>-------------------------------------------
>
>[79] pinyin suggestions are somewhat shown.
>
>[80] pinyin several keys are not working; :;().?!
>
>[81] swedish input, the kr key is sent as k
>
>[82] Media key doesnt work (vol up/down)
>
>
>iPad iOS v7.1.1 - Safari - HW Keyboard (Apple Wireless)
>-------------------------------------------------------
>
>[83] Failed to produce any char using altgr + 1-9 eg @
>
>[84] ESC is not sent into session.
>
>[85] Lost of focus eg. clipboard turns keyboard input off.
>
>[86] command, ctrl, alt or shift is not sent into session as their
>corresponding key, however as example (Shift_L + a) sends a virtual
>shift key press and produces correctly a uppercase a.
>
>[87] ctrl key produces (Shift_L + Meta_L) into session.
>
>[88] Pressing another deadkey after an initial deadkey produces a
>backspace.
>
>[89] No dead keys works
>
>[90] F1-F12 is not sent into session.
>
>[91] No media keys works
>
>[92] Caps-lock is sent as Control_L + <key>, sometimes there is
>no KeyRelease send for key and sometimes no KeyRelease for Control_L
>
>
>
>iPad iOS v7.1.1 - Chrome v34.0.1847.18 - Virtual Keyboard
>---------------------------------------------------------
>
>I can't even log in to a session, hangs here and there during loading
>of resource.
>
>
>Android - Chrome v34.0.1847.114 - Virtual Keyboard
>--------------------------------------------------
>
>[93] Many symbols are sent into session but no symbol shown for the
>following symbols; â¢ â Î  â â¢ â 
>
>[94] Suggestions are shown which breaks expected behaviours if used.
>
>[95] Pinyin, broken in several ways, cant write any words not even space
>or enter sends any key presses.
>
>[96] Pinyin, 123 keyboard, colon sent but with shift_l
>
>[97] Pinyin, symbols not sent into session; ~ â¦ â â 
>
>[98] No media keys works (Volume Up/Down)
>
>
>Android - FireFox v29.0.1 - Virtual Keyboard
>--------------------------------------------
>
>[99] Many symbols are sent into session (noname) but no symbol is
>matched and shown for the following; â¢ â Î  â â¢ â
>
>[100] Pinyin, ï¿¥ is not sent into session.
>
>[101] Pinyin, Parenteses on second screen is sent as backspace and
>ISO_Left_Tab.
>
>[102] Pinyin, There are a lot of symbols sent as noname and some not
>sent at all into session.
>
>[103] No media keys works (Volume Up/Down)
>
>
>Android - Chrome v34.0.1847.114 - Hardware Keyboard (USB)
>---------------------------------------------------------
>
>[104] Failed to produce any char using altgr + 1-9 eg. no @
>
>[105] Shift got stuck and with no corresponding key release is sent
>
>[106] altgr sent as Alt_L
>
>[107] Right ctrl, shift sent as corresponding left key
>
>[108] left windows key sent as Super_R
>
>[109] right windows key sent as (Shift_L + Hyper_L)
>
>[110] None of the dead keys are sent into session.
>
>[111] Without numlock, no keys are working except for; / * - + keys.
>
>[112] With numlock, all keys works except for; enter
>
>[113] With numlock, comma is sent as period
>
>[114] Menu key is trapped by browser
>
>[115] Pause not sent into session
>
>[116] Print screen, trapped locally
>
>[117] No media keys are working
>
>
>Android - FireFox  - Hardware Keyboard (USB)
>--------------------------------------------
>
>[118] Failed to produce any char using altgr + 1-9 eg. no @
>
>[119] altgr sent as Alt_L
>
>[120] Right ctrl, shift, alt sent as left counterpart
>
>[121] Both windows keys sent as (Shift_L + Meta_L)
>
>[122] Dead key ' send as = into session
>
>[123] No dead keys works
>
>[124] Without numlock, / * - + and enter works as expected, ther rest of
>the keys produces wrong symbols (keys 1-9 produces symbols a-i) etc.
>
>[125] With numlock, everything works as expected except that comma is
>sent as period.
>
>[126] Menu key is trapped by browser
>
>[127] Pause not sent into session
>
>[128] Print screen is trapped locally
>

Actions: View

Attachments on bug 4865: 542